ArthurinCali’s Thoughts
ArthurinCali’s Thoughts
Sign in
HomePodcastNotesChatArthurinCaliDiscordArchiveLeaderboardAbout

Reflections on AI Images & History

It is more of a mirror that is held to our belief of the narratives.

Arthur in California's avatar
Arthur in California
May 1
Frank Herbert quote: Technology is both a tool for helping ...

What I've noticed is that many dismiss images AI creates based on historical settings. "That's just AI's version of it" is the usual refrain. But isn't everything we are taught about history itself just a version that has been agreed upon?

AI is no different as it takes what information it has been provided to create what it thinks we want to see.

Thank you for reading ArthurinCali’s Newsletter. This post is public so feel free to share it.

Share

Here are some time periods imagined by AI:

Image
The 1900s show promise, possibilities, and a vibrant civilization.

1900s America

Here it shows images of an expanding nation and her people. The robust American spirit of growth and ingenuity.

Image
1920s is a collage of vibrant street scenes.

1920s America

A busy city street, roaring 20s flappers and optimism are on display with this image. A nation who knows itself and the direction it (thinks) wants to go.

Image
1930s. Even through hardship, the resolve and determination is on display.

1930s America

A montage of Great Depression shots. They still capture the hope that folks had that things were going to get better.

Image
1940s AI breathes life into that time period.

1940s America

Excellent time capsule. A girl in a diner looking forlorn as she waits for her GI to come home from the war, a couple stealing on more stroll before he heads back to the front.

Image
1950s. Probably my favorite.

1950s America

The post-WW2 optimism of the country seems to shine through with these images. Elegant women, class and style of the period is seen clearly.

Image
1960s. The diminishment begins slightly in the images.

1960s America

The cultural upheaval and societal change reveals itself in the lower right image. AI captures the beginnings of national unrest.

Image
The 1970s are captured nicely here.

1970s America

Classic 70s Americana throughout.

Image
Why is McDonald’s so important to AI for these 1980s portraits?

1980s America

The consumerism of the 80s jumps out at me with these. Funny how Mcdonald's is so prominent for the 80's and what AI conjured up. I almost imagine a clueless 1950s woman looking over the cyberpunk sprawl in the 3rd picture.

Image
1990s AI hints at how far things were falling even if most didn’t notice it yet.

1990s America

The blight and miasma of America begins to show through these images. The blank stare, entropy of structures and a sense of loss.

Image
2000s. What is this supposed to mean?

2000s America

A question of who, exactly, is America reveals itself in the 2000s. While prior timeframes include Americans, this is just cluttered landscapes and visual word salad. The empty diner reflects the fracturing of ties amongst society.

Image
2020-present. Shapeless and without meaning or purpose.

2020 America

Merely a jumble of slogans and ideas are the current iteration that AI sees when it creates images of a current American age. While other timelines exhibited a nation made of her people, this one shows the fracturing of it. Any of these could be standard graphics from a pulp New York Times article on the blessings of our “Sacred Democracy™️,” or another Atlantic diatribe extolling the virtues of the latest screed written in book form on how horrible America was (or currently is) according to whatever Leftist writer thinks.

ArthurinCali’s Newsletter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

AI image generation is able to tell us more about ourselves and the current condition of the civilizational psyche than we care to admit.

Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Otto Hawker's avatar
Otto Hawker
May 16, 2024

This was pretty scary

Like (1)
Reply
Share
1 reply by Arthur in California
Vengefulsun's avatar
Vengefulsun
May 24, 2024

That was actually quite interesting. I always love it when people use things creatively to create something else, in this case AI, to tell a story. There isn't a necessity for a discussion about the lifelessness or soullessness of AI, then. Listen to the raw output of a synthesizer, as an (imperfect) analogy, but when put in the right hands, it's a beautiful instrument.

Like
Reply
Share
1 more comment...

Keep reading

ArthurinCali’s Thoughts

GWOT veteran that writes on news, politics, history, and culture from a Right-Wing perspective. Also, military stories and the occasional review.

  • About
  • Archive
  • Recommendations
  • Sitemap
© 2026 ArthurinCali · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.